How do you calculate a percentage discount?
As of 18 November 2026. Scope: EU law and Germany (§ 11 PAngV, the German Price Indication Ordinance).
Your percentage discount refers to the prior price. Under Art. 6a(2) of Directive 98/6/EC, that is the lowest price you applied during a period of not less than 30 days before the reduction. In Germany, § 11(1) PAngV refers to the last 30 days. A higher last selling price does not work as a base. The CJEU decided this on 26.09.2024 in case C-330/23 (Aldi Süd).
The formula is: percentage discount = (1 − promotional price ÷ prior price) × 100.
The Commission guidance of 2021 works through an example (section 2.1). If a reduction is announced as “50% off” and the lowest price in the preceding 30 days was 100 EUR, the seller must state 100 EUR as the prior price and calculate the 50% from it. This applies even if the last selling price was 160 EUR.
We calculated the two examples below ourselves. They do not come from the sources.
Example 1: higher last selling price
| Item | Value | Formula |
|---|---|---|
| Last selling price before the promotion | 160 EUR | |
| Lowest price of the last 30 days | 100 EUR | |
| Promotional price | 70 EUR | |
| Discount based on the prior price | 30% | (1 − 70 ÷ 100) × 100 |
| Arithmetical discount based on the last selling price | about 56% | (1 − 70 ÷ 160) × 100 |
Anyone advertising “56% off” here bases the figure on the last selling price. Under the judgment and the guidance, the comparison value is the lowest price of the last 30 days, which is 100 EUR in the example.
Example 2: earlier special price within the period
According to the guidance, the lowest price includes every reduced price you charged in that period (section 2.1). A product normally costs 120 EUR, was briefly on offer for 90 EUR ten days before the new promotion and now costs 72 EUR.
| Item | Value | Formula |
|---|---|---|
| Regular price | 120 EUR | |
| Earlier special price within the 30 days | 90 EUR | |
| Promotional price | 72 EUR | |
| Discount based on the prior price | 20% | (1 − 72 ÷ 90) × 100 |
| Arithmetical discount based on the regular price | 40% | (1 − 72 ÷ 120) × 100 |
You can state 20% here. The 40% rests on a price that is not the prior price.
What was C-330/23 about?
The Regional Court of Düsseldorf (Landgericht Düsseldorf) had referred two questions to the Court of Justice (request for a preliminary ruling of 19.05.2023). Behind them was a dispute between Verbraucherzentrale Baden-Württemberg eV (consumers’ association of the Land of Baden-Württemberg) and Aldi Süd over price reductions in an advertising leaflet for groceries (paragraphs 2 and 10).
The leaflet for the week of 17 to 22.10.2022 advertised bananas and pineapples, among other things, as reduced. Each price tile showed the current price, a struck-through price and the text “Last selling price. Lowest price in the last 30 days:” followed by a third price. For the bananas a percentage was added, for the pineapples the addition “Preis-Highlight” (price highlight) (paragraph 11).
The first question referred asked whether a percentage in a price reduction may be based exclusively on the prior price within the meaning of Art. 6a(2). The second asked the same for promotional highlights such as “Preis-Highlight” (paragraph 17).
What did the Court decide?
The operative part of the judgment says in essence: a price reduction announced as a percentage, or in the form of a promotional statement intended to highlight the advantageous nature of the price, must be determined on the basis of the prior price. A “promotional statement on the advantageous nature” means additions such as “Preis-Highlight” that present the price as particularly low. The Court interpreted Art. 6a(1) and (2) of Directive 98/6/EC.
The reasoning contains three points with a direct effect on your price indications:
- The reduction is determined from the prior price. It is not enough to state the prior price merely as additional information while the percentage rests on a different value. That would allow consumers to be misled with unreal price reductions (paragraph 26).
- The promotional price must be lower. The selling price stated as reduced cannot be as high as, or even higher than, the prior price (paragraph 27).
- Art. 6a takes precedence. Art. 6a specifically regulates the indication of the prior price. The announcement of a price reduction that is not determined on the basis of the prior price is therefore assessed under Art. 6a. The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive steps back in this respect (paragraph 28).
The Commission had formulated the same principle in its 2021 guidance: any percentage reduction stated must be based on the prior price. The Court cites this passage in paragraph 9.
May you also state the RRP or another price?
The guidance (section 2.1) says that Art. 6a does not prevent the seller from stating further reference prices. The condition is that they are clearly explained, cause no confusion and do not distract attention from the indication of the prior price. According to the guidance, how such additional prices are calculated and presented continues to be assessed under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.
On the comparison with the recommended retail price (RRP), the guidance says in section 3: such a price comparison does not fall under Art. 6a. The seller must, however, take the utmost care that the average consumer does not perceive the comparison as a price reduction. If they do, the advertising can infringe both sets of rules. The guidance is an interpretive aid by the Commission without legal force.
Open: The Court did not decide whether, next to the prior price, a percentage based on the RRP or another reference price is permissible. It was not the subject of the questions referred (paragraph 17). Under paragraph 28, any announced price reduction that is not based on the prior price is assessed under Art. 6a. A claim such as “−56% against RRP” in a discount promotion therefore carries, in our assessment, an open legal risk. Legal advice should clarify this question.
How the rule deals with RRP indications and price comparisons overall is explained in the article Omnibus Directive in the online shop.
What does this mean for discount promotions in your shop?
The following points are recommendations of the editorial team. No norm prescribes them in this form.
- Calculate percentage claims and “You save” amounts from the lowest price of the last 30 days.
- Check promotional terms such as “Preis-Highlight” or “top price” when they sit next to a price reduction. The operative part mentions promotional statements meant to highlight the advantageous nature of the price.
- Before the start, compare the promotional price with the prior price. If it is not below it, the reduction claim does not hold under paragraph 27.
- Document the prices of the last 30 days for each product. Many shop systems store only the current price and a strike-through price. How this looks in Shopify is described in the article Shopify EU obligations.
What remains open?
The judgment does not work out any reduction. It only describes the prices of the original case (paragraphs 11 and 13). It also does not settle how the prior price is to be determined for new products under 30 days. On that, the position remains as described in the article on the Omnibus rule.
These points are also open:
- whether a percentage relating to the RRP or another reference price is permissible next to the prior price (see above),
- whether “You save EUR X” claims are to be treated like percentages, because the judgment does not mention them expressly,
- how a promotional statement on the advantageous nature of a price is delimited, for example “top price” without a struck-through price.
Questions about an individual promotion belong with legal advice.
Next steps
- Black Friday: Omnibus checklist for the price indications in your promotion
- Black Friday legal checklist for online shops for the remaining duties
- Duty check for the legal guarantee notice
Not legal advice. Garanify currently implements the display obligations of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1960 technically; further modules are in preparation.